The Smokey Eye vs. The Red Lip

There are many celebrities who tend to have a signature look... either the smokey eye or the red lip. But what happens when they decide to switch it up and try something new?!?! Is it a complete disaster, or does it look absolutely amazing? Here's some pictures of celebs sporting the classic red lip vs. smokey eye. What looks best? You decide!

Jennifer Lopez

Beyonce

Gwen Stefani

Angelina Jolie

Kim Kardashian

Megan Fox

Hayden Panettiere

Kate Hudson